Taste, judged blind
Three independent blind Fable judges each saw captures of the existing site, then the kits in shuffled, lettered order, as native-size PNGs with their original pixels. Each judge had its own letters. A fourth judge, Codex, reviewed independently. The rubric, the prompts, the versions and the pictures are recorded with the test.
The full method and every kit are in the blind test.
The floor, checked by a program
Some faults need no judge. board check renders each piece and fails it for clipped text, text off the canvas, overlapping text, small text, unloaded fonts and contrast below WCAG. It writes a receipt and sets exit status 1.
Taste, written down
DESIGN.md carries the part of taste a designer can hand over: each part named by its job, how it is built, how it recomposes, and the voice from the real pages. Freeze records the exact styles next to it.
Questions and answers
Can taste be distilled into a style guide?
Yes, the part a designer hands over: DESIGN.md carries it. The finished pictures are then judged blind.
How were the kits hidden from the judges?
Each judge saw the kits under its own shuffled letters, at native size, with no tool names.
Is Briefatto Board free?
Yes. It is open source under the Apache-2.0 licence and installs with npx briefatto-board install.