# Can you test design taste in AI-made work?

Updated 2026-11-21 · https://briefatto.com/guides/can-design-taste-be-tested/

Yes, by judges who cannot see which tool made what: in our blind test on one real open-source project, three blind Fable judges and a Codex judge ranked four kits, and all 4 of 4 put the Briefatto Board kit first overall. The floor under taste, such as clipped text, unloaded fonts and low contrast, is the job of a program, `board check`.

## Taste, judged blind

Three independent blind Fable judges each saw captures of the existing site, then the kits in shuffled, lettered order, as native-size PNGs with their original pixels. Each judge had its own letters. A fourth judge, Codex, reviewed independently. The rubric, the prompts, the versions and the pictures are recorded with the test.

The full method and every kit are in [the blind test](https://briefatto.com/guides/impeccable-vs-taste-skill-vs-hallmark-blind-test/).

## The floor, checked by a program

Some faults need no judge. `board check` renders each piece and fails it for clipped text, text off the canvas, overlapping text, small text, unloaded fonts and contrast below WCAG. It writes a receipt and sets exit status 1.

## Taste, written down

DESIGN.md carries the part of taste a designer can hand over: each part named by its job, how it is built, how it recomposes, and the voice from the real pages. Freeze records the exact styles next to it.

## Questions and answers

### Can taste be distilled into a style guide?

Yes, the part a designer hands over: DESIGN.md carries it. The finished pictures are then judged blind.

### How were the kits hidden from the judges?

Each judge saw the kits under its own shuffled letters, at native size, with no tool names.

### Is Briefatto Board free?

Yes. It is open source under the Apache-2.0 licence and installs with `npx briefatto-board install`.

## Try it

```
npx briefatto-board install
```

Briefatto Board is free and open source under Apache-2.0: https://github.com/Briefatto/briefatto-board

## Related guides

- [Design checks as scripts instead of prompts: how board check works](https://briefatto.com/guides/deterministic-design-checks-vs-prompts/)
- [How do you avoid AI slop in agent-built UI?](https://briefatto.com/guides/how-to-avoid-ai-slop-ui/)
- [How do you write a good DESIGN.md that an agent can use?](https://briefatto.com/guides/how-to-write-a-good-design-md/)
- [Why do AI-built sites all look the same, and how do you fix it?](https://briefatto.com/guides/why-ai-built-sites-look-the-same/)
- [Briefatto Board vs Impeccable, Taste Skill and Hallmark: the blind test](https://briefatto.com/guides/impeccable-vs-taste-skill-vs-hallmark-blind-test/)

## Sources

- https://github.com/Briefatto/briefatto-board/blob/main/README.md
- https://github.com/Briefatto/briefatto-board/blob/main/src/board/cli.ts
- https://github.com/Briefatto/briefatto-board/blob/main/skill/briefatto-board/SKILL.md
- https://github.com/Briefatto/briefatto-board/blob/main/LICENSE
