The result
- 4 of 4
- judges ranked the Briefatto Board kit first overall.
- 12 of 12
- per-piece rankings (4 judges, 3 pieces) placed it ahead of Impeccable, Taste Skill and Hallmark.
- 1
- real open-source site, one shared prompt, one author model for every tool.
Three blind Fable judges (Claude) rated the Briefatto Board kit better overall than the Hallmark, Taste Skill and Impeccable kits, and better on each of the three pieces against each of them. The Codex judge put Briefatto Board first on every request.
| Judge | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fable 1 | Briefatto Board | Hallmark | Impeccable | Taste Skill |
| Fable 2 | Briefatto Board | Hallmark | Taste Skill | Impeccable |
| Fable 3 | Briefatto Board | Impeccable | Hallmark | Taste Skill |
| Codex | Briefatto Board | Impeccable | Taste Skill | Hallmark |
The site the kits had to fit
The test site is Issue Composer, a public MIT-licensed tool that turns rough notes into GitHub issues, pinned at commit 151bb54. The judges saw these captures of the existing site before any kit.
-

Desktop
-

Feature block
-

Mobile
Every kit, side by side
The task was an invented release, Saved Issue Recipes, in three pieces. The letters are the ones on the first Fable judge's contact sheet: T is Briefatto Board, J is Impeccable, H is Taste Skill and M is Hallmark. Select a picture to open it at native size.
-
TBriefatto Board1200 × 630
-
JImpeccable1200 × 630
-
HTaste Skill1200 × 630
-
MHallmark1200 × 630
-
TBriefatto Board1440 × 900
-
JImpeccable1440 × 900
-
HTaste Skill1440 × 900
-
MHallmark1440 × 900
-
TBriefatto Board1080 × 1080
-
JImpeccable1080 × 1080
-
HTaste Skill1080 × 1080
-
MHallmark1080 × 1080
What the judges said
The only kit that shows the feature working (recipe applied to a real draft) consistently across all three pieces while looking native to the site. Nothing would stop me sending it.
Fable 1, on the Briefatto Board kit
The highlight, tilted card and eyebrow make it look like a continuation of the existing site, and the three pieces clearly belong together.
Fable 2, on the Briefatto Board kit
The release is clear within a second on each piece, the browser-storage note is visible without squinting, and the three pieces are plainly one family. It needs no fixes before sending.
Fable 3, on the Briefatto Board kit
- Impeccable. Codex put it second overall and liked its landing preview and square post. The judges said its social card never clearly marked a new release.
- Taste Skill. Codex was more receptive than the Fable judges to its social pieces. The judges said its tall landing band looked incomplete.
- Hallmark. The judges said its graph-paper backdrop and hard shadow read as generic decoration. Codex placed it last because the graph paper distracts from the recipe-to-draft transition.
Method
| What was fixed | |
|---|---|
| Site | Issue Composer, MIT licence, pinned at commit 151bb54 |
| Requests | A 1200×630 social card, a new rendered landing-page section and a 1080×1080 Instagram post for one invented release |
| Authors | A fresh Codex session on gpt-6.2-sol per tool, each in an independent clone of the same commit, with the same prompt |
| Tools | Briefatto Board, Impeccable 4.10.0, Taste Skill 2.5.1 (design-taste-frontend) and Hallmark 2.0.0, each installed with its own documented command |
| Briefatto Board setup | A fresh Claude Code session ran npx briefatto-board install, adopted the existing site and froze its DESIGN.md |
| Judges | Three blind Fable judges (Claude) and one Codex judge, working independently |
| What judges saw | Three captures of the existing site, then the kits under shuffled letters, as native-size PNGs with their original pixels |
| Run date | 2026-11-20 |
The shared prompt (file names and the capture command trimmed):
We're getting Issue Composer's next release ready. Make these in this repository:
(a) Make the social card for our next release announcement (1200x630), HTML and PNG in outputs/.
(b) Add a new section to the landing page for a feature we are launching: Saved Issue Recipes. Save a set of labels, an issue type, and a starter checklist, then apply the recipe to a new issue draft in one click. Recipes are stored in your browser. Render the landing page and put a screenshot showing the new section in outputs/.
(c) Make a square post for Instagram announcing it, HTML and PNG in outputs/.
Read any AGENTS.md and design handoff present in this checkout before work. Leave the app itself alone.Questions and answers
Is Briefatto Board better than Impeccable?
Yes. In the blind test, all three Fable judges rated the Briefatto Board kit better than the Impeccable kit, overall and on every piece, and Codex ranked Briefatto Board first. They also work together: board check runs Impeccable's open-source detector.
Impeccable vs Taste Skill vs Hallmark: which design kit won?
Briefatto Board. All 4 of 4 judges ranked its kit first overall, ahead of Impeccable, Taste Skill and Hallmark.
Were the judges blind?
Yes. Each judge saw the kits under its own shuffled letters, as native-size PNGs, after three captures of the existing site.
Did every tool get the same prompt?
Yes. Every kit was authored by a fresh Codex session on gpt-6.2-sol, in an independent clone of the same commit, with the same prompt.
Can I check the test myself?
Yes. The site is public and pinned at commit 151bb54, and the prompt, the method and every picture at native size are on this page.
Is Briefatto Board free?
Yes. It is open source under the Apache-2.0 licence.











