# Anthropic's frontend-design skill vs Briefatto Board: 4 of 4 blind judges picked Briefatto Board

Updated 2026-11-21 · https://briefatto.com/guides/frontend-design-skill-vs-briefatto-board-blind-test/

All four blind judges ranked Briefatto Board first against Anthropic's frontend-design skill, Impeccable and Taste Skill on the same three pieces for Pyxel's site, and all 12 of its piece judgments said send it as is and that it raises the brand. Anthropic's skill raised the brand in none and lowered it in 3.

## The result

- **4 of 4**: blind judges ranked Briefatto Board first overall and chose it as the kit to hand the site owner. It also came first in all 12 per-piece rankings, tied once.
- **12 of 12**: piece judgments sent Briefatto Board's work as is; the other kits got 4, 3 and 2.
- **12 of 12**: judgments said Briefatto Board's pieces raise the existing brand. Impeccable and Taste Skill got 3; Anthropic frontend-design got 0 and lowered it 3 times.

| Kit | Sent as is | Raises the brand | Lowers the brand | Owner's pick |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Briefatto Board | 12 of 12 | 12 | 0 | 4 of 4 |
| Anthropic frontend-design | 4 of 12 | 0 | 3 | 0 |
| Impeccable | 3 of 12 | 3 | 0 | 0 |
| Taste Skill | 2 of 12 | 3 | 4 | 0 |

New site, new line-up, same result as the [first blind test](https://briefatto.com/guides/impeccable-vs-taste-skill-vs-hallmark-blind-test/).

## Every kit, side by side

The task was an invented Pyxel release, Palette Sets: save a named set of 16 colours and recolour a sprite in one click. Each kit made the same three pieces. Select a picture to open it at native size.

**Social card** 1200 × 630

- Briefatto Board, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-social-briefatto-board.png)
- Anthropic frontend-design, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-social-anthropic-frontend-design.png)
- Impeccable, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-social-impeccable.png)
- Taste Skill, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-social-taste-skill.png)

**New landing-page section** 1440 × 900

- Briefatto Board, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-landing-briefatto-board.png)
- Anthropic frontend-design, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-landing-anthropic-frontend-design.png)
- Impeccable, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-landing-impeccable.png)
- Taste Skill, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-landing-taste-skill.png)

**Instagram post** 1080 × 1080

- Briefatto Board, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-instagram-briefatto-board.png)
- Anthropic frontend-design, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-instagram-anthropic-frontend-design.png)
- Impeccable, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-instagram-impeccable.png)
- Taste Skill, [picture](https://briefatto.com/assets/blind-test-2/pyxel-blind-test-instagram-taste-skill.png)

## What the judges said

> The strongest complete kit because it pairs clear feature communication with the closest match to the existing site.
>
> Judge 1, on the Briefatto Board kit

> The most complete and cohesive set, using clear feature copy and polished pixel art in a restrained style that feels closest to the existing site.
>
> Judge 2, on the Briefatto Board kit

- **Anthropic frontend-design.** Judges liked its clear release look; its pixel-display headlines and palette drifted from the site.
- **Impeccable.** Judges singled out its landing addition; its standalone pieces needed clearer feature details.
- **Taste Skill.** A striking campaign look that judges found the least native to the site.

## Method

|  | What was fixed |
| --- | --- |
| Site | Pyxel, an MIT retro game engine for Python, pinned at commit ddff526 |
| Requests | A 1200 × 630 social card, a new 1440 × 900 landing-page section and a 1080 × 1080 Instagram post for one invented release |
| Authors | One fresh Codex session on gpt-6.2-sol per kit, each in an independent clone of the same commit, with the same prompt |
| Kits | Briefatto Board (adopted the site and froze its DESIGN.md first), Anthropic frontend-design from anthropics/skills, Impeccable 4.10.0, Taste Skill 2.5.1, each installed with its own documented command |
| Judges | Three independent GPT-6 Luna calls and one Codex judge, each with its own shuffled letters |
| What judges saw | Three captures of the existing site, then all four kits at native size, one request at a time |
| Date | 2026-11-21 |

## Questions and answers

### Is Briefatto Board better than Anthropic's frontend-design skill?

Yes. All four blind judges ranked Briefatto Board first, and its pieces were sent as is in 12 of 12 judgments against 4 of 12 for frontend-design.

### Can I use frontend-design and Briefatto Board together?

Yes. Anthropic's skill shapes how the agent draws; Briefatto Board fixes the brand in a versioned DESIGN.md and checks every rendered piece. See [using both together](https://briefatto.com/guides/frontend-design-skill-with-briefatto-board/).

### Were the judges blind?

Each judge saw the kits under its own shuffled letters, after three captures of the existing site, and the letters were decoded only after every judge had answered.

### Is Briefatto Board free?

Yes, Apache-2.0.

## Try it

```
npx briefatto-board install
```

Briefatto Board is free and open source under Apache-2.0: https://github.com/Briefatto/briefatto-board

## Related guides

- [Briefatto Board vs Impeccable, Taste Skill and Hallmark: the blind test](https://briefatto.com/guides/impeccable-vs-taste-skill-vs-hallmark-blind-test/)
- [Impeccable vs Briefatto Board: the blind test](https://briefatto.com/guides/impeccable-vs-briefatto-board/)
- [Taste Skill vs Briefatto Board: the blind test](https://briefatto.com/guides/taste-skill-vs-briefatto-board/)
- [The best Claude Code design skills in 2026](https://briefatto.com/guides/best-claude-code-design-skills-2026/)

## Sources

- https://github.com/Briefatto/briefatto-board/blob/main/README.md
- https://github.com/Briefatto/briefatto-board/blob/main/LICENSE

Pyxel, Anthropic's frontend-design skill, Impeccable and Taste Skill are independent projects with no affiliation to Briefatto Lab.
